Hold employers accountable for labour abuses; do not turn migrant workers into scapegoats

The South African Federation of Trade Unions (SAFTU) is concerned by the Department of Employment and Labour’s report recording 231,850 foreign nationals employed at 21,371 workplaces among the 168,766 workplaces inspected by the end of the second quarter of the 2026/27 financial year.

Agriculture recorded 46,533 foreign nationals across 1,205 employers, while wholesale and retail recorded 41,359 across 6,698 employers. The report also identifies community services, manufacturing, hospitality, construction, mining, private security, financial services and education among the sectors employing foreign nationals.

These figures demand serious investigation and effective enforcement. But they do not, on their own, show how many workers were undocumented, whether labour laws were breached, what wages workers received, or how many South Africans worked at those same workplaces. Nor do they establish that every foreign national found in an entry-level job displaced a South African jobseeker.

The Department must publish the information needed to understand what its inspections uncovered: workers’ immigration and work-permit status, occupations, wages and hours, compliance with the National Minimum Wage and bargaining council agreements, and the number of South African workers at the inspected workplaces. The public also needs to know how many employers were found non-compliant, what notices or penalties they received, and whether those employers were re-inspected.

The responsibility for labour-law violations lies with employers. It is employers who decide whom to hire, set wages and working conditions, and are legally responsible for compliance. Employers who recruit vulnerable workers to evade minimum wages, benefits, bargaining council agreements or other labour protections must face real consequences. Workers, whether South African or foreign, must not be pitted against one another while unscrupulous employers benefit from low wages and insecure work.

South Africa’s unemployment crisis is undeniable. Statistics South Africa’s latest figures show 8.6 million people unemployed in the third quarter of 2026. The official unemployment rate was 33.7%, while the expanded measure that includes people who want work but are not actively searching stood at 44%. The broader labour-underutilisation measure, LU4, was 46.3%.

That crisis cannot be solved by blaming migrants. It requires an economic and industrial strategy that creates decent, secure jobs, strengthens public employment services, and prevents employers from exploiting workers through precarious and informal employment.

SAFTU believes the Employment Services Amendment Bill and the National Labour Migration Policy must be debated openly and carefully. Any sector-specific measures or quotas must be based on credible labour-market evidence, transparent criteria and meaningful consultation with organised labour. They must not become a licence for discrimination or a substitute for creating jobs and enforcing labour standards. The Bill proposes stronger regulation and enforcement, and gives the Minister powers related to labour migration and sector measures.

All workers must enjoy the protection of labour laws. Foreign workers are especially vulnerable when employers use their insecure status to intimidate them, underpay them or prevent them from organising. Protecting those workers and enforcing equal standards helps prevent employers from using one group of workers to drive down conditions for everyone.

The Department’s reliance on Project 10,000 to recruit additional inspectors recognises that enforcement requires capacity. But recruitment must be matched with adequate funding, training, transport and operational support. Inspections must lead to follow-up visits and meaningful penalties where employers persistently break the law. A report that counts workers without showing what action was taken against non-compliant employers is not enough.

SAFTU calls on the Department to release the full inspection findings, strengthen its inspectorate, and report publicly on enforcement outcomes. Government must ensure that every employer complies with labour law and that every worker can work with dignity, security and equal protection.

A statement was issued on behalf of SAFTU by the General Secretary, Zwelinzima
Vavi.

For media inquiries, contact the National Spokesperson at
Newton Masuku
066 168 2157
Newtonm@saftu.org.za
Media Officer
Asive Dyani
0719019564

Please follow and like us: